 You Are Justified to Doubt in Descarte's Meditation 1 of Meditations on First Philosophy
Rene Descartes' Meditations on First Philosophy was the definitive work that laid the groundwork for our western worldview. This is particularly true in the first chapter, Meditation 1, which justifies the backbone of the scientific method and our modern way of thinking. That backbone is skepticism and doubt.
It might seem that doubt is the enemy of belief. But Meditation 1 proved the opposite by carefully showing that doubt is the foundation of a strong belief system. Descartes' essay in Meditation 1 brilliantly demonstrates that when one applies skepticism and doubt to all aspects of how we evaluate truth, that is the only valid way to support or disprove any belief system in spiritual matters.
It is in the later chapters beyond Meditation 1 that Descartes goes on to apply the fundamentals of doubt and the testing of truth that Meditation 1 establishes for the rest of the work. This is why Meditations on First Philosophy must be a core document for the support of our belief systems in science or in spiritual principles. Meditation 1 is important if we are to feel confident in supporting any belief system that makes up our worldview.
The process of doubt that Descartes describes in Meditation 1 is aggressive and unrelenting. Instead of examining individual tenants of his belief system, Descartes goes back to applying a skeptical view to the very heart of how we come to know the world, our senses. His conclusion in Meditation 1 that even the senses can be fooled resonates with the reader's experience as well. The very fact that the senses we use as our only way of understanding the world can be easily tricked introduces doubt into a system of logic and scientific method that depends on observed truth to make sense.
Meditation 1 provides something that is often missing in most dialogs about the validity of spiritual matters or even of our knowledge of the world. That missing element is objectivity. By applying the same standards of evaluation on the validity of the senses as proof of the natural world, Meditation 1 becomes a fair standard for the evaluation of spiritual matters including the existence of God in the later meditations of the book.
Despite the fact that Meditation 1 as part of the Meditations on First Philosophy is a philosophical essay that is over 300 years old, it is compelling and important to us today. Descartes' writing style is intellectual and yet digestible at the same time. The discussions of the dream life as part of the justification for doubt of the senses are full of colorful and even humorous illustrations.
The result is that a rational reader will come away from Meditation 1 with a new appreciation for skepticism and how it should be leveraged against all aspects of our knowledge of this world and our understanding of truth. It is good to linger in Meditation 1 for one's own understanding of the world we live in. And it lays an excellent grounding for the in depth discussions coming in the later meditations that make up Descartes' Meditations on First Philosophy.
|
|
|
